A recent High Court case has brought the devastating loss of a family in Cork to light, reminding us of the fragility of trust placed in medical professionals and the importance of legal recourse. Aileen Halligan, a mother of three and a grandmother to four, tragically passed away following what was supposed to be a routine heart angiogram at the Mater Private Hospital in Cork. Her story is a heartbreaking but critical example of how things can go wrong and the significance of holding medical institutions accountable.
If you or a loved one have experienced a similar tragedy, this article will not only outline the details of this case but also provide insights into pursuing justice through a medical negligence claim.
The Story Behind the Tragedy
Aileen Halligan, a retired nurse from Cobh, Co Cork, underwent an angiogram in May 2017. Despite the routine nature of the test, it was combined with an angioplasty procedure to treat a blockage in the blood vessels. It was during this stenting procedure that complications arose. The stent reportedly became displaced, leading to thrombosis, heart failure, and ultimately Aileen’s untimely passing.
Her family sued the consultant interventional cardiologist involved, citing failures in duty of care, including a lack of warning about the risks associated with the stenting procedure. Leaving a family devastated, the case was brought before the High Court. Seven years later, the family reached an out-of-court settlement of €420,000, though without any admission of liability.
Aileen’s daughter, Aoife Halligan Brown, spoke movingly in court, recounting the trauma of her mother’s final moments. Her words powerfully underscored the emotional toll of medical negligence, describing chaotic scenes at the hospital and the lasting impact on their family.
“Monetary compensation is in fact little or no compensation for the dreadful loss we have suffered,”
she expressed.
“Our mum should be with us today.”
This case amplifies the voices of countless families who seek justice and accountability for their loss. But it also serves as a reminder that victims of medical negligence deserve more than closure—they deserve systemic change to prevent such tragedies in the future.
What is Medical Negligence?
Medical negligence occurs when a healthcare professional fails to provide the standard of care expected, leading to injury or harm to a patient. This can stem from actions or omissions during treatment. Not every medical outcome amounts to negligence, but certain conditions must be met for a successful claim:
- A Duty of Care existed between the medical professional and the patient.
- A Breach of Duty occurred when the professional failed to meet the standard expected of them.
- The breach directly caused harm or injury, known as Causation.
Examples of medical negligence include:
- Misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis
- Surgical errors
- Failure to obtain informed consent
- Medication errors
- Negligence during childbirth or pregnancy
Aileen Halligan’s case falls under surgical errors and failure to inform the patient adequately about potential risks, which tragically led to her death.
When to Consider a Medical Negligence Claim
If you or someone close to you has experienced substandard medical care resulting in injury or death, a medical negligence claim may be the next step. Some questions to consider include:
- Did the healthcare provider fail to act as a similarly skilled professional would in the same situation?
- Was there a failure to inform you of the risks involved in the treatment?
- Did the negligence result in injury, harm, or loss?
It’s worth consulting with specialised medical negligence solicitors to help determine whether you have grounds for a case. Firms like HOMS Assist have extensive expertise in handling these delicate matters with care and professionalism.
Understanding the legal process can empower families seeking justice while highlighting areas where healthcare systems can improve.
The Legal Process for Medical Negligence Claims
Navigating a medical negligence claim involves multiple steps. Here’s a brief overview of the process:
1. Initial Consultation
Speak with an experienced solicitor to discuss the details of your case and determine its viability. Most solicitors will provide an initial consultation free of charge.
2. Medical Records Review
Your solicitor will request and thoroughly examine all relevant medical records to identify evidence of negligence. Often, an independent medical expert is hired to assess the care you received.
3. Letter of Claim
If negligence is established, your solicitor will issue a letter of claim to the responsible party outlining the case and seeking resolution, often in the form of financial compensation.
4. Negotiation and Settlement
Many cases are resolved through negotiation or out-of-court settlements, as seen in Aileen Halligan’s case. However, if necessary, the claim may proceed to court.
5. Outcome
If your claim is successful, you may be awarded compensation to cover financial losses, medical expenses, emotional distress, and, in fatal cases, statutory mental distress payments to family members.
Time is a critical factor in pursuing a claim. Under Irish law, you generally have two years from the date of the incident to initiate proceedings.
Why Legal Representation is Crucial
Cases like Aileen Halligan’s demonstrate the complexity of medical negligence claims. Legal experts bring necessary experience and knowledge to:
- Advocate effectively on your behalf
- Understand and address the nuances of medical evidence
- Stand up to powerful healthcare institutions
- Provide the emotional support needed during difficult times
Experienced firms like HOMS Assist have helped countless families secure justice and contribute to reform in healthcare standards. With over 55 years of legal expertise, their services are underpinned by compassion and professionalism, making them a trusted partner for victims of medical negligence.
Contact HOMS Assist today for personalised advice and support.
Moving Forward and Preventing Future Tragedies
While no amount of compensation can truly replace a lost loved one, pursuing justice is essential. It not only helps families find closure but also sheds light on healthcare system failures that require improvement. Victories in cases like Aileen Halligan’s can set precedents, ensuring accountability and encouraging better standards of care.
The Halligan family’s courage to seek justice honours Aileen’s memory and serves as a poignant reminder for medical institutions to prioritise patient safety above all else.
If you or someone you love has experienced medical negligence, don’t hesitate to seek support. Taking action today may pave the way for a safer tomorrow.
Contact HOMS Assist to book a confidential consultation about your situation and explore your options for achieving justice.
