Beyond the ‘But-For’: Rethinking Causation in Tortious Claims

In the intricate world of tort law, causation is the linchpin determining the success of a claim. But with evolving complexities in cases, particularly those involving multifactorial causes, is it time to move past the ‘but-for’ test? It’s not just an academic query; it’s a pressing issue affecting countless claimants whose cases are derailed by an outdated legal framework.

The Complexity of Causation

The traditional ‘but-for’ test asks a seemingly simple question,

“Would the injury not have occurred but for the defendant’s actions?”

While this is effective in straightforward cases, its rigidity fails in complex scenarios such as occupational diseases or clinical negligence, where multiple factors or parties contribute to the harm. Here, the standard test often leads to unjust outcomes.

Real-world Cases and Their Challenges

Consider the case of Quinn v Mid Western Health Board in Ireland. Despite acknowledging negligence, the court adhered to the standard causation test and dismissed the claim due to other contributing factors. This left the claimant without recourse, highlighting the limitations of the ‘but-for’ approach.

In contrast, courts in England and Wales have adopted a more flexible stance. For instance, in Bonnington Castings v Wardlaw, the court acknowledged a ‘material contribution’ to the harm, allowing recovery even when the defendant’s actions weren’t the sole cause. This adaptation of the traditional causation test marks a significant step towards fairness in multifactorial cases.

Legal Principles and Precedents

The principle of ‘material contribution’ offers hope for claimants facing multifactorial causation issues. It acknowledges that a contribution to harm that is more than negligible suffices for liability. This was pivotal in McGhee v National Coal Board, where the plaintiff’s exposure to brick dust was deemed a substantial cause of dermatitis, despite multiple potential sources.

However, the application of ‘material contribution’ comes with its own challenges, as courts must distinguish between divisible and indivisible diseases. In Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services Ltd, the modified test ensured justice for plaintiffs with mesothelioma, an indivisible disease, even when causation couldn’t be pinpointed to a single source.

Addressing Industry Challenges

Reluctance to depart from traditional causation tests is understandable, given the potential for increased litigation complexity. Yet, maintaining the status quo risks perpetuating injustices. Claimants deserve a legal system reflecting modern life’s realities.

The Irish case of Holmes v Poeton Holdings Ltd underscores the consequences of inaction. The plaintiff’s claim was dismissed due to insufficient evidence linking exposure to Parkinson’s Disease. Such outcomes underscore the need for a flexible approach to causation.

A Call for Change

The time has come for legal systems to evolve and consider alternatives to the ‘but-for’ test. By adopting principles like ‘material contribution’, we can ensure that deserving claimants aren’t dismissed due to technicalities. This shift requires courage and foresight, but the benefits far outweigh the challenges.

For those navigating the complexities of tortious claims, expert legal guidance is crucial. If you face challenges with causation in your claim, contact us for tailored advice. Our team is dedicated to ensuring your voice is heard and that justice prevails, regardless of the intricacies involved.

Conclusion

Rethinking causation isn’t merely about refining legal doctrine—it’s about ensuring fairness and justice for those wronged. Let’s work together to create a legal system that serves all its constituents. Contact us today to explore how we can assist you in navigating your claim effectively.

Get in touch

Nationwide services with dedicated offices in

Dublin

2-4 Ely Place, Dublin 2, D02 FR58

Limerick

Bishopsgate, Henry Street, Limerick, V94 K5R6

Cork

1A South Mall, Cork, T12 PV44

Share this page

OTHER SERVICES

service

Estate Planning Solicitor: Wills, Probate and Trusts

HOMS Assist provide swift case resolution and a personalised service. Contact us for all private wealth cases such as Wills and Powers of Attorney.

service

Property Law Solicitors

HOMS Assist provide swift case resolution and personalised service in Dublin and Limerick. Contact us today to discuss property law matters.

service

Medical Negligence Claims

HOMS Assist have 50+ years’ experience in offering medical negligence solicitor services in Ireland. Contact us today for expert advice and prompt case settlement.

RELATED ARTICLES

Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015: AB Ruling Clarifies Rights-Based Principles

News Article

Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015: AB Ruling Clarifies Rights-Based Principles

How Lower Interest Rates and Government Support are Opening Doors for First-Time Buyers

News Article

How Lower Interest Rates and Government Support are Opening Doors for First-Time Buyers

Child Injury Claims: Comprehensive Legal Support and Guidance - child injury claims, legal support for children, personal injury solicitor

News Article

Keeping Children Safe and Seeking Justice When Accidents Happen

Expert Legal Support for Holiday Injury Claims - Holiday injury claims, Package holiday compensation, Irish travel accident solicitor

News Article

Handling Holiday Accidents and Personal Injury Claims with Confidence

Tax Implications of Selling an Inherited Property - inheritance tax Ireland, Budget 2025 tax strategies, Irish property tax planning

News Article

Tax Implications of Selling an Inherited Property

Product Safety: Your Ultimate Guide to CE Marking and Safe Gifting - Product Safety, CE Marking, Christmas Gifting Hazards

News Article

Product Safety: How to Buy Safe Gifts This Christmas

What we offer

We are an award winning, client-oriented law firm in Dublin, Limerick and Cork. Our solicitors provide comprehensive legal advice in an approachable and caring manner. Most of us will require a solicitor at some time in our lives. When the time comes that you do require legal support you will want to be sure that you are dealing with professionals who will work quickly and efficiently to help you. So whether you need help writing a Will, you have been in an accident, suffered an injury or illness that was not your fault, or you are looking at divorce options, we can offer clear guidance and representation to assist you in obtaining the optimum result.

Request a callback

Fill out the form below, and we will contact you shortly. Required fields are marked *

Sign up to our newsletter today

Scroll to Top